There were several comments in my post about PDFs and Flash media about the iPad in particular. Evidently, it won't be supporting Flash. Is this a problem?
I don't intend to antagonize you Apple fans out there, but I don't "get" the iPad. Before you descend upon me with a vengeance, let me explain.
There are an incredible number of electronic devices that tempt us these days. Each has a primary purpose and often a secondary purpose, perhaps even a number of them. For example, my Timex watch has as its primary purpose time functions — a clock, an alarm, a timer. But, it also will store 100 phone numbers should I choose to keep them there. I don't, but I could. Storing phone numbers is a secondary purpose that has nothing to do with its primary purpose even though it's a neat add-on. For some folks, this secondary purpose may be an important enough add-on feature to have influenced their watch purchase. It wasn't for me, so that feature is unused.
The Nintendo Wii, the X-Box, and the Sony PlayStation all are primarily game playing devices. They have other, secondary functions too, like playing DVD movies on your TV, playing music CDs, or connecting to the Internet. Neat, but not a driving reason to own one. If I want to play a DVD movie, I'm more likely to use my DVD player. If I want to surf the Internet, I'm more likely to go to my computer. The secondary purpose of a device is not valueless, but it's not a driving reason to buy it.
My AM/FM portable radio has an auto-on feature that is touted as a wake-up alarm. I've never used it.
The Kindle and the Sony Reader have the primary purpose of book and news reading. As a secondary purpose they also will play a slide show of photos and play MP3 files. Okay, but I wouldn't buy them as a slide show device nor as a replacement for an iPod.
Many MP3 players — primarily music players — can also show JPEG images or even videos. I doubt they are sold for these secondary purposes.
My cell phone is, surprisingly, primarily a phone. Barely, but that's the reason I purchased it — to call people and talk with them. Beyond that primary purpose, I can also play games, keep an appointment calendar, surf the web, record voice notes, use it as a count-down timer, take still pictures and movies, and play MP3 and podcast audios. That it can do all of these things does not mean, however, that I'm willing to give up my PlayStation, Day-timer, computer web browser, Olympus pocket recorder, kitchen timer, camera, video camera, or my Sansa Fuze MP3 player.
In all these examples, there is a primary purpose that drives the reason for the device to exist. All the other stuff is secondary — nice, convenient to have I suppose, but there are always better devices for these secondary purposes — devices whose primary purpose is dedicated to that function and that do it better than the secondary use on some other device. The idea of a universal hardware device is seductive, but in practice falls short. Look at your own pile of electronics. I'll bet you have lots of redundancy and unused secondary features just like I do.
Which brings me back to the iPad. For the life of me, I cannot figure out what the primary purpose of an iPad is. It seems like a technology searching for a reason to exist. It's a bundle of secondary purposes for which there doesn't seem to be a primary purpose. It's cool; it's neat; it looks to be a fun device, but to what primary purpose?
- It's a computer, sort of, but it won't multitask and has a funky keyboard. It won't replace my desktop, my laptop, nor my netbook.
- It's a movie player, sort of, but where do I stick the DVD in and why wouldn't I just take a portable DVD player on the plane for a fraction of the cost of an iPad?
- It's an Internet device, sort of, but if it won't play Flash files, won't I still need a browser on a computer for universal content delivery?
- It's an e-book reader, sort of, but it doesn't seem to have the advantages of dedicated e-readers that use e-ink when it comes to eye-strain and battery life.
- It's too bulky to replace my MP3 player.
- It's not a camera, not a phone, not a Skype device, not an audio recorder.
- I guess it will play games, sort of, but won't a Sony PSP do a better job of this?
Like I say, I can't quite figure out its primary purpose — other than to be a really neat hardware device from Apple that has all the "wow-factor" Apple is famous for. Without a primary purpose, however, I don't understand how it fits into the market and what it will make obsolete. With the iPhone and the iPod, Apple has primary purpose devices that provide outstanding performance and ground-breaking technology. I just don't see that in the iPad — but I'll probably be proven wrong in time.